Prime Cut & Catch

Mastering the Perfect Medium-Rare Cowboy Ribeye

The star of any true surf and turf experience is undoubtedly the steak, and for this recipe, we’ve chosen the magnificent cowboy ribeye. This cut is a bone-in ribeye, often thicker and with a longer bone handle than a standard ribeye, which not only adds an impressive visual flair but also contributes significantly to the flavor. The bone acts as a natural insulator, slowing down the cooking process around it, resulting in a more evenly cooked interior and a richer, more profound beefy taste.

To achieve that coveted steakhouse quality, simplicity is key. A balanced blend of coarse ground black pepper, sea salt, garlic powder, and onion powder is all you need. This classic seasoning mix enhances the steak’s natural flavors without overpowering them. Generously apply the rub to all sides of the cowboy ribeye, ensuring every inch is covered, and gently pat it in to help it adhere to the meat. Allow the steak to sit at room temperature for about 30 minutes before grilling; this helps it cook more evenly.

The Art of Dual-Zone Grilling for Steak Perfection

For a truly perfect medium-rare cowboy ribeye with a beautiful crust, a dual-zone grilling setup is indispensable. This technique involves creating two heat zones on your grill: one for indirect cooking at a lower temperature, and another for direct, high-heat searing. Start by preheating your grill to an initial temperature of 250 degrees Fahrenheit. If you’re using a charcoal grill, arrange your coals to one side; for gas grills, simply turn off one or more burners to create a cooler zone.

Begin the cooking process by placing the cowboy ribeye on the indirect side of the grill. This slow, gentle cook allows the steak to gradually come up to temperature, promoting tenderness and even doneness throughout. Monitor the internal temperature with a reliable meat thermometer; you’re aiming for approximately 120 degrees Fahrenheit. This reverse-sear method, while taking about an hour, is the secret to a perfectly cooked interior.

Once your steak reaches the target internal temperature, it’s time for the glorious sear. Increase your grill’s temperature to a scorching 500 degrees Fahrenheit on the direct heat side. Place the cowboy ribeye directly over the high heat and sear each side for about 2 minutes. This brief, intense heat creates that irresistible, deeply browned crust (Maillard reaction) that adds incredible flavor and texture. For a flawless medium-rare, the final internal temperature of the steak should be around 128 degrees Fahrenheit. Remember, carryover cooking will slightly increase the temperature even after it’s removed from the grill.

The final, crucial step is resting the steak. Once seared, remove the cowboy ribeye from the grill and let it rest on a cutting board for a minimum of 10 minutes. This period is vital for any cooked protein, allowing the muscle fibers to relax and the juices, which have been driven to the center during cooking, to redistribute evenly throughout the meat. Skipping this step results in a dry steak, as all those precious juices will escape onto your plate when you cut into it. A well-rested steak guarantees a tender, juicy slice every time.

Elevate Your Grilling Game with Premium Seasonings!

Unlock deeper flavors and achieve consistent results with must-have grilling seasonings. Whether it’s a steak, chicken, or vegetables, the right blend makes all the difference. Explore a range of savory rubs designed to transform your ordinary meals into extraordinary culinary delights!

Order Now

Grilling Succulent Giant Shrimp

No surf and turf is complete without the “surf,” and for this dish, we’re focusing on large, plump shrimp that grill beautifully. When sourcing your shrimp, opt for giant or jumbo varieties (16-20 count per pound) for a more substantial and satisfying bite. If you purchase whole, shell-on shrimp, the first step is proper deveining. To do this, make a shallow cut along the top of the shrimp’s back, from head to tail, and carefully remove the thin, dark intestinal tract. It’s crucial not to remove the shell at this stage, as it provides a protective barrier during grilling, helping the shrimp retain moisture and infusing them with more flavor as they cook.

Once deveined, toss the shrimp with a light coating of olive oil. The oil helps the seasoning adhere and prevents the shrimp from sticking to the grill grates. For seasoning, a bold Cajun blend works wonders, adding a delightful kick that complements the richness of the steak. Ensure the shrimp are evenly coated, but avoid over-seasoning, as the natural sweetness of the shrimp should still shine through.

Preheat your grill to a steady 400 degrees Fahrenheit, setting it up for direct heat. The key to perfectly grilled shrimp is high heat and quick cooking to prevent them from becoming rubbery. Once the grill is hot, place the seasoned shrimp directly on the grates. Grill for approximately 1.5 minutes per side. You’ll know they’re ready when they turn opaque and pink, with a slight char and curl. Avoid overcooking at all costs, as shrimp can go from perfectly tender to tough in a matter of seconds. Serve immediately for the best texture and flavor.

Crafting Homemade Compound Herb Butter

To truly elevate your surf and turf, a homemade compound herb butter is an absolute game-changer. This flavorful butter not only adds incredible richness and a punch of fresh herbaceousness to both your steak and shrimp but also demonstrates an extra touch of culinary finesse. The best part? It’s surprisingly simple to make and can be prepared in advance, storing beautifully in the refrigerator for future use. This versatility makes it a staple for any home cook looking to enhance their dishes.

For the best results, start with a higher quality unsalted butter. Premium butter typically has a higher butterfat content, which translates to a richer flavor and a smoother texture in your compound butter. Ensure the butter is at room temperature before you begin; this is critical for achieving a smooth, evenly blended mixture without lumps.

In a medium mixing bowl, combine one stick of softened unsalted butter with finely chopped fresh parsley, rosemary, and sage. These herbs offer a classic, aromatic profile that pairs wonderfully with both beef and seafood. Next, add freshly grated garlic (avoid pre-minced for superior flavor), a pinch of salt to balance the flavors, and a touch of crushed red pepper flakes for a subtle warmth and zing. Using a fork or a spatula, thoroughly mix all the ingredients together. Continue to mash and blend until the butter is completely smooth and the herbs and spices are evenly incorporated throughout.

Once your herb butter is perfectly blended, transfer the mixture onto a sheet of plastic wrap. Carefully form it into a tight log shape, rolling the plastic wrap firmly to ensure a compact cylinder. This shape makes it easy to slice later. Place the wrapped butter log into the refrigerator for at least an hour, or until it has firmed up considerably. The hardening process allows the flavors to meld beautifully and makes it much easier to cut into neat, uniform slices.

When your homemade herb butter has reached the desired firmness, it’s time to add the finishing touch to your surf and turf. Place a few generous slices of the cold compound butter directly onto your hot, rested cowboy ribeye. The residual heat from the steak will gently melt the butter, creating a luscious, herb-infused sauce that cascades over the meat. For the grilled shrimp, you can either add a dollop of butter or gently melt a small amount and drizzle it over the succulent crustaceans. This final step not only adds a burst of flavor but also contributes to the dish’s irresistible aroma and presentation. Enjoy this truly homemade steakhouse surf and turf experience!

Frequently Asked Questions: Surf & Turf Edition